Case studies in low-energy district heating systems Determination of dimensioning methods for planning the future heating infrastructure

Technical University of Denmark (DTU) Denmark, hatol@byg.dtu.dk

The climate crisis and the new technological possibilities for building the low energy buildings give the opportunity to transform the municipal heating systems from high temperature, and high demand systems to low temperature, and low demand systems. The heating demand will be reduced significantly in the future and renewable energy has to be integrated in the design of district heating systems in proper with the non-fossil fuel based future. The paper suggests a plan for an energy efficient District Heating (DH) system with low operating temperatures, such as 55 °C in terms of supply and 25 °C in terms of return. Different case studies could be the rational basis for the integrated planning of the future’s sustainable and energy efficient heating infrastructure. Firstly, consideration was given to define an optimal dimensioning method for a new settlement where low-energy houses are planned to be constructed within a case study in collaboration with Roskilde Municipality, Denmark. In this case study focus was given to the determination of the optimal substation configuration equipped at each house and optimal network layout to prevent excessive supply temperature drop occurring in summer months. The use of optimization method yielded in energy savings of 14% in terms of heat loss from the DH network, in comparison to mostly used traditional dimensioning method based on pressure gradient. Also, considering a storage tank at each substation of the houses at the low-energy DH network resulted in energy savings of 8% in preventing the heat loss from the DH network in comparison to the use of substation without storage tank. The use of by-passes at the end-users in a branched DH network could save significant energy in the point of heat loss from the DH network in comparison to forming the low-energy DH network with looped layout. Second consideration was given to define an optimal dimensioning of low-energy DH network in connection with existing settlement and with existing citywide heating system. The technical aspect of using low-temperature at existing inhouse heating systems was also investigated in collaboration with Gladsaxe Municipality, Denmark. This case is used to form the operational planning. The peak-demand conditions were defined to be supplied with boosted temperature, allowing further reduction of pipe dimensions at the design stage. The existing houses in the case area were considered to be renovated to low-energy class. Dimensioning the low-energy DH network with consideration given to current heat demand situation yielded in 41% higher pipe investment cost in comparison to the pipe dimensions achieved by use of boosted supply temperature at peak-demand conditions. Thus overdimensioned DH network for the future situation could be avoided by considering current and future heat demand situations together with boosting the supply temperature in some certain peak situations.

[1] LUND H., MÖLLER B., MATHIESEN B.V., and DYRELUND A. “The role of district heating in future renewable energy systems”. Energy, Vol. 35, 2010, pp.1381-1390.

[2] LUND H., and MATHIESEN B.V. “Energy system analysis of 100% renewable energy systems—The case of Denmark in years 2030 and 2050”. Energy, Vol. 34, 2009, pp. 524-531.

[3] LUND H. “Renewable energy systems: the choice and modeling of 100% renewable solutions”. MA, USA: Elsevier Science & Technology.

[4] SØRENSEN TOREKOV M., BAHNSEN N., and QVALE B. “The relative competitive positions of the alternative means for domestic heating”. Energy, Vol. 32, 2007, pp. 627-633.

[5] ALBERG ØSTERGAARD P., MATHIESEN B.V., MÖLLER B., and LUND H. A renewable energy scenario for Aalborg Municipality based on low-temperature geothermal heat, wind power and biomass. Energy, Vol. 35, 2010, pp. 4892-4901.

[6] MÖLLER B., and LUND H. “Conversion of individual natural gas to district heating: Geographical studies of supply costs and consequences for the Danish energy system”. Applied Energy, Vol. 87, 2010, pp. 1846-1857.

[7] BRISTOW D., and KENNEDY C.A. “Potential of building-scale alternative energy to alleviate risk from the future price of energy”. Energy Policy, Vol. 38, 2010, pp. 1885-1894.

[8] PAULSEN O., FAN J., FURBO S., and THORSEN J.E. “Consumer Unit for Low Energy District Heating Net”, in: The 11th International Symposium on District Heating and Cooling 2008, Aug 31 – Sep 2, Reykjavik, Iceland.

[9] OLSEN P.K., LAMBERTSEN H., HUMMELSHØJ R., BØHM B., CHRISTIANSEN C.H., SVENDSEN S. et al. “A new low-temperature district heating system for low-energy buildings”, in: The 11th International Symposium on District Heating and Cooling, 2008 Aug 31 – Sep 2, Reykjavik, Iceland.

[10] CHRISTIANSAN C.H., WORM J., JØRGENSEN H., THORSEN J.E., BENNETSEN J., LARSEN C.T. et al. “Demonstration of low energy district heating system for low energy building in Ringgårdens Afd. 34 in Lystrup [Demonstration af lavenergifjernvarme til lavenergibyggeri i boligforeningen Ringgårdens Afd. 34 i Lystrup] [in Danish]”, Teknologisk Institut, EUDP 2008-II, 2011 Maj, 104 p.

[11] CHRISTIANSEN C.H., PAULSEN O., BØHM B., THORSEN J.E., TING LARSEN C., JEPSEN B.K. et al. “Development and demonstration of low-energy district heating for lowenergy buildings. Main report and appendices [Udvikling og demonstration af lavenergifjernvarme til lavenergibyggeri. Hovedrapport og bilag] [In Danish]”, Teknologisk Institut, EFP 2007, 2009 March, 173 p.

[12] WILTSHIRE R. “Low temperature district energy systems” in: 16th Building Services, Mechanical and Building Industry Days, 2011 Oct 14 – 15, Debrecen, Hungary.

[13] SSE. “Zero carbon home development”. Available: http://www.ssezerocarbonhomes.com/.

[14] MERTOĞLU O., DOKUZ İ., CANLAN A., and BAKIR N. “Alternative energy sources and low temperature geothermal district heating [Alternatif enerji kaynakları ve düşük sıcaklıklı jeotermal bölgesel ısıtma] [In Turkish]”, Tesisat Mühendisliği, Vol. 55, 1999, pp. 917-929.

[15] PERSSON U., and WERNER S. “Heat distribution and the future competitiveness of district heating”. Applied Energy, Vol. 88, 2011, pp. 568-576.

[16] REIDHAV C., and WERNER S. “Profitability of sparse district heating”, Applied Energy, Vol. 85, 2008, pp. 867-877.

[17] TOL H.İ., and SVENDSEN S. “Improving the Dimensioning of Piping Networks and Network Layouts in Low-Energy District Heating Systems Connected to Low-Energy Buildings: A case study in Roskilde, Denmark”. Energy, In Press.

[18] TOL H.İ., and SVENDSEN S. “Design of low-energy district heating system for a settlement with low-energy buildings”, in: 3rd International Symposium on Environmental Management, 2011 Oct 26-28, Zagreb, Croatia, pp. 166-171.

[19] TOL H.İ., and SVENDSEN S. “Determination of optimum network layout for low-energy district heating systems with different substation types”, in: The Third International Renewable Energy Congress, 2011 Dec 20-22, Hammamet, Tunisia, pp. 166-171.

[20] FOGED M. “Low temperature operation”, DBDH, Vol. 1, pp. 1-3.

[21] WINTER W., HASLAUER T., and OBERNBERGER I. “Simultaneity surveys in district heating networks: Results and project experience [Untersuchungen zur Gleich-zeitigkeit in Nahwärmenetzen : Ergebnisse und Projekterfahrungen] [In German]”, Euroheat&Power, Vol. 30, pp. 42-47.

[22] LOGSTOR, “The twinpipes - Logstor product catalog”, 2009, (modified: 2011 July, cited: 2011 August). Available: http://www.logstor.com/.

[23] THORSEN J.E., CHRISTIANSEN C.H., BRAND M., OLESEN P.K., and LARSEN C.T. “Experiences on low-temperature district heating in Lystrup – Denmark”, in: International Conference on District Energy, 2011 March 20-22, Portorož, Slovenia.

[24] BRAND M., DALLA ROSA A., and SVENDSEN S. “Performance of low temperature district heating systems for low energy houses”, in: The Future for Sustainable Built Environments with High Performance Energy Systems; 2010 Oct 19-21, Munich, Germany, pp. 174-183.

[25] BRAND M., THORSEN J.E., and SVENDSEN S., and CHRISTIANSEN C.H. “A direct heat exchanger unit used for domestic hot water supply in a single‐family house supplied by low energy district heating”, in: The 12th International Symposium on District Heating and Cooling, 2010 Sep 5-7, Talinn, Estonia, pp. 60-68.

[26] LI H., DALLA ROSA A., and SVENDSEN S. “Design of low temperature district heating network with supply water recirculation”, in: The 12th International Symposium on District Heating and Cooling, 2010 Sep 5-7, Talinn, Estonia, pp. 73-80.

[27] LANGENDRIES R. “Low return temperature (LRT) in district heating”, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 12, 1988, pp.191-200.

[28] HASAN A., KURNITSKI J., and JOKIRANTA K. “A combined low temperature water heating system consisting of radiators and floor heating”, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 41, 2009, pp. 470-479.

[29] PEDERSEN L., STANG J., and ULSETH R. “Load prediction method for heat and electricity demand in buildings for the purpose of planning for mixed energy distribution systems”, Energy and Buildings, Vol. 40, 2008, pp. 1124-1134.

[30] Erhvervs og Byggestyrelsen, “Building class 2020 [Bygningsklasse 2020] [in Danish]”. Copenhagen: Erhvervs og Byggestyrelsen; 2011 June 1. p. 33 Available: www.ebst.dk.

[31] KARLSSON T., and RAGNARSSON A. “Use of Very Low Temperature Geothermal Water in Radiator Heating Systems”, in: World Geothermal Congress, 1995 May, pp. 2195-2198.

[32] SERHAN K. “The thermal effects of some control logics used in GDHS”, Applied Thermal Engineering, Vol. 27, 2007, pp. 1495-1500.

[33] DALLA ROSA A., and CHRISTENSEN J.E. “Low-energy district heating in energy-efficient building areas”, Energy, Vol. 36, 2011, pp. 6890-6899.

[34] TOL H.İ., and SVENDSEN S. “Operational planning of low-energy district heating systems connected to in-house heating systems equipped at existing buildings”, in: International Conference on Renewable Energy: Generation and Applications, 2012 Mar 4-7, Al-Ain, UAE, in Press.

[35] ODGAARD O., and JØRGENSEN M.H., “Heat Supply in Denmark - Who What Where and Why”, The Danish Energy Authority, 2005 Jan, 40 p.

[36] ODGAARD O. “Basic Facts on Heat Supply in Denmark”, The Danish Energy Authority, Available: http://www.ens.dk/.

[37] O'KELLY G., and RAHIKAINEN A. “European Biomass Review - New Comprehensive Analysis and Forecast of the European Bioenergy Sector”. RISI, Available: http://www.risiinfo.com/.

[38] SKM. “Ministry of Taxation and DEA investigation of barriers to utilization of industrial waste heat [Skatteministeriets og Energistyrelsens undersøgelse af barrierer for udnyttelse af industriel overskudsvarme] [in Danish]”, Skatteministeriet, 2006 Juni, 27 p.

[39] MAHLER A., and MAGTENGAARD J. “Geothermal Development in Denmark, Country Update”, in: World Geothermal Congress, 2005 Apr 24-29, Antalya, Turkey, pp. 1-8.

[40] DYRELUND A. “Heat Plan Denmark – Low Carbon Urban Heating”, Rambøll, CTR FRB 2009, 23 p.

[41] DFG. “Geothermal energy in Denmark [Geotermi i Danmark] [in Danish]”. Dansk Fjernvarmes Geotermiselskab, Available: http://www.geotermi.dk/.

[42] JOHNSON CONTROLS, “York Heat-Recovery Chillers”, 2009 May, Available: www.johsoncontrols.com/.